Thanks for the feedback!
We can thank @fleer for the fact that we’re using these emoji reactions. I originally used an up and down voting system and Fleer made the case for having these kind of reaction emojis and I quickly realized that he was right. I then interviewed each member of my family — except our cat — and everyone agreed that…Read More

A community to share thoughts about music, and visit the DEALS page… haha.

Amusing typo and the editing function is presently not available (please don’t delete it!!!!) , but I consider the forum functionality complete. I will swap out the read / unread function if a bunch of folks want it because I’ve already tested it and it didn’t cause any conflicts with other scripts (the biggest concern when adding a new script /…Read More

@Brian, as I have said before, I am partly colour blind and I cannot really see the difference between the green and the grey exclaimation points. To you the difference may be obvious but not to me. A number of people have suggested using something with more contrast; I guess I don’t understand the resistance to doing that. Does the current system…Read More

@Doug. My apologies- I didn’t catch your post about color blindness. I actually brought that up to Peter a couple days ago. He said he is going to change the icon shapes to make the difference clearer. Right now it is green on white for un-read, and gray on white for read. That is likely indistinguishable for you, unfortunately. I think they…Read More

@bluescat, no worries. @peter has already reached out and I have offered to find some icons that might work. I had taken Peter’s comment that the site was feature complete to mean that green and gray exclaimation points were what was going to be used to identify read/unread messages. That was not his intent at all.

Yep, you’re correct. We did have the ability to edit posts — but lost it when I installed some pretty significant enhancements on the site. The developer responsible for those enhancements is looking into the issues and if they can’t resolve them, they have some additional plugins I can purchase that do the same thing. So it’s easy to get the…Read More

It’s not just you. I posted about that yesterday to make everyone aware of the issue and that I’ve put in a trouble ticket with the developer of this functionality (a different developer than the theme developer I usually refer to; there are plugins/scripts from A LOT of different developers on this site). We’ll get it fixed. And you know, there’s…Read More

Oups, I must have missed that post. Thanks for all the hard work! I naïvely thought setting up a forum would be a simple task. Was I wrong or what! 🙂

Love it, thanks!

Seeing your comment made my day! Thanks for sharing your candid feedback.

@patrickwichrowski made an excellent observation — that the contrast between the two images isn’t ideal and I think he’s right. So, I’m going to be replacing those with something that has more contrast. If you can think of any sites where you’ve seen images to represent…Read More

I agree that thre isn”t enough difference in the two icons. Maybe an exclamation point for unread and a checkmark when read. An other alternative is an exclamation point for unread and nothing when read.

On the lighter side, I did realize that when I tagged Release in the poll that I probably unintentionally killed any possibility to see anyone who was going to vote “it’s alright” or “I don’t really like it” from voting as they’re like — um, no, Peter can see my vote and he’ll tag me next! Sorry folks, I’ll try to wait a bit longer next time.…Read More

I liked the system with the blue stripe for unread posts. It made it very obvious what was read and unread. Is that the one people found unintuitive? Being slightly colour blind I can’t really distringuish between the green and the gray of the current system. Maybe I just got used to it but I really liked the system the old forum had of having a…Read More

I was told by two people that it didn’t work. I don’t recall hearing from anyone else, so I assumed that it had problems and moved on.

@blackjackschellac It make take several days, but the plugin allows me to upload my own graphic, so in the next several days I’ll replace it and I’m very interested in hearing or seeing screenshots of forums where you think the icons they use are highly intuitive.

I am not part of many forums, so I can’t really suggest any graphics unfortunatly. I am part of this forum and cakewalk’s and visit other site’s when searching for specific help. But I suggest keeping it simple. The most important thing is visibility. The Cakewalk forum has a simple dot in front of the title when unread that disappears when read.…Read More

Just spitballing here. It’s a very small element, so a U in reverse on a green circle for unread. When a topic of forum is read it remains a ball, but with a revetse R out of gray. But it could just as well be a checkmark because it’s so small

Yes, when it is small details are difficult to see at a glance which is what we want for this. I have done some looking on the internet and from what I saw, I believe you could use the activity icon you already have. 3 dots in it when it is unread and a checkmark when it is read. I also realised, from some of the comments I saw, is that we must be…Read More

That surprises me that people said stripes didn’t work. It worked great for me and was exactly what I was looking for. Did they DM you about it or was it part of a thread? If part of a thread, then I missed the discussion. Anyway, what you are now proposing would be fine as well,

I’m pretty sure it.was either the thread for people to report fixes or a thread in the Earky Adopters Group. I realize that sometimes the issues are that folks don’t understand how to use something. I wish I remembered which one had the stripes so I could note it. I take it you like that better than the one we’re using now?

The stripes made it very easy to see what was read and unread. If the current system would do that, then I would be fine with it. As it stands now, I cannot tell the difference between read and unread so the current system is useless to me.

The current system is the first one where I’ve had positive feedback. But if MOST people agree they want a prior system — and because I’ve installed, I think, a total of 4 different systems, I can’t recall which one had the blue bars, but I’d replace this one if a bunch of members can agree to it. Feel free to do a poll just like I did below –…Read More

@peter I am not against the current system. Just used different icons for read/unread to help us poor color challenged folk.

@doug You must have missed the discussion, but I’m going to create new icons that are specifically considering those who are color blind. I have a long history of managing / leading digital marketing, including corporate websites at three major global brands. While it was EXTREMELY unpopular among the next level up (I’ll try not get sued), I…Read More

@peter I did not miss the discussion on accomodating colour blind people. Brian tagged me and asked if I did not see the exclaimation marks showing read and unread messages. I responded saying I saw the exclaimation marks but not the difference between green and gray. Then I was confused by your statement about the forum being functionally…Read More

@peter, I have responded to your DM with more discussion on this topic.

@doug By functionally complete I only meant that I was finished adding new features for version one. I definitely 100% support anything I can do (within the constraints of my budget) to make the site more accessible. There’s no end date for that. That is about human beings. No, I absolutely planned on getting this fixed as soon as it was pointed…Read More

The number under a member’s username in the forum represents how many forum topics that user has created. It’s no surprise that @cclarry blows away everyone else. Last I noticed, Larry’s number was, I think, over 230 and mine is not even 10 percent of that. I think mine is currently at around 17 and I built this site. I just haven’t had time to do…Read More

Thanks for the feedback. My take was that I enjoy seeing when new people join, but the notices were just way too big and I couldn’t find a way to reduce the size, so they’re gone now. Don’t ever hesitate to share your thoughts if you think there’s some functionality that you really enjoy, or other functionality you think isn’t really adding value.…Read More

Talented songwriters. I love a lot of different styles of music, and have loved The Eagles since I was s kid.

I saw him about two years ago and was fortunate enough to get his set list from the stage where he left it (I was in the front row) He came out after and signed albums/CDs he was selling and was very gracius. He was scheduled to tour this fall with Karla Bonoff.

Karla Bonoff, that’s a name I haven’t heard in a while.

I personnaly miss the old days of the Cakewalk forum. I truly enjoyed participating and helping tecnically when I could. I am sad not being part of the energy that made the Cakewakl experience for 5 years. Interacting with the devs was great. They are very competent and responded in the best way possible when bugs and new ideas were submitted.

I still like the CW forum, don’t get me wrong Banning you was stupid, but look what happened

BTW deleting all of pwalpwal’s posts was very cruel☹️

@oldjoad Did BandLab do that or did you misunderstand what I did this morning? I’ve made several posts at the site — including a side wide notification for people to post in the private thread for two reasons (1) it keeps things more manageable for me to have things in a single place and not a bunch of threads, and (2) the issues thread is…Read More

Someone at bandlab deleted all pwalpwal’s posts. I’m not even gonna ask what you did this morning😎

@oldjoad Why did they do that? Was it an accident or intentional? It’s bizarre how BandLab operates. What’s up with billionaire trust fund kids and their businesses these days?

I think they did it because pwalpwal was standing up for you guys, it happened like the day after they kicked you guys out. They didn’t ban him but they deleted thousands of his post. a stern warning I guess.

This was some of the conversation:

Thanks for the feedback! And thanks for being a part of it.